The Alternative Regulator without Hairpring - TAG Heuer Pendulum Concept

May 30, 2010,22:35 PM
 


TAG Heuer continues in its quest to rethink out of the box with another 'under the nose reinvention', after substituting the traditional pinion and gear transmission with a belt-driven mechanical transmission (which many thought it could not be achieved when it was announced in 2004, and started shipping last November)  with "the first mechanical movement without hairspring".

To celebrate its 150th anniversary this year, TAG Heuer announced a rework of the regulation system which was nearly unchanged since the creation of the Galileo-inspired hairspring by Christiaan Huygens in 1675, and a material improvement (Invar and Elinvar) reducing thermal sensitivity by Charles-Edouard Guillaume, winning him the Nobel Prize for Physics in 1920.

Though this regulation system with the hairspring/spiral and balance wheel is still being used till today, it is understood to have inherent isochronal issues.

The alternative 6-Hz (43,200 VPH) regulation system of the TAG Heuer Pendulum Concept intends to tackle the typical regulation system challenges by removing the hairspring which is the lynchpin of every movements and also the controlling component which most watch companies have yet to be able to manufacture.

Instead of the hairspring, the replacement is with a 'virtual spring' derived from magnets.  A flash of the Seiko's Tri-synchro regulator (for more information, please click here) with electromagnetic braking is inevitable. 

However, upon watching the video, the TAG Heuer Pendulum Concept is without any electronics! 




The schematic of the Pendulum Concept Regulation unit


Extracted from the press material :

" ...The complete device forms a harmonic oscillator. The magnetic field, generated by means of 4 high-performance magnets and controlled in 3D through complex geometric calculations, provides the linear restoring torque necessary for the alternative oscillations of the balance wheel. The oscillating period of the TAG Heuer Pendulum Concept is resistant to changes from perturbing forces, which is what makes it an exceptionally good timekeeping device. The movement built with this revolutionary oscillator is fully mechanical and does not contain any electronics or driven actuators..."


The above statements are closely related to the topic of 'Q factor' of oscillator. 

A well written article by  Velociphile , touched on  the 'Q-factor' and also about  increased accuracy of high beat escapements on isochronism improvement , is a good read and relevant to the above concept.

The issue facing the Pendulum concept which TAG Heuer admitted is the magnet is sensitive to temperature.  The company will continue their R&D work with Integrated Actuators Laboratory, part of the Microtechnics Institute of Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Lausanne (EPFL), hopefully to discover the magnetic equivalent of invar-elinvar.

This project will take the combined efforts of material scientists, engineers and watchmakers ....and I am eager to see TAG Heuer finalizing the alternative regulating system in the coming years.

For now, here are some pictures and videos of the prototype
TAG Heuer Pendulum Concept Watch.

Enjoy!

Kong




A filmlet illustrating the alternative regulating system.  Please allow like 7 to 10 seconds to load.




Diameter was not in the specification, however TAG Heuer replied the diameter is 47mm.


 

 


The magnetic 'balance' at rest.  The small second at 4 o'clock location.


















Note the smooth gliding second-hand ...











 




The steel case design remains faithful to the GRAND CARRERA with polished angled edges ....


and curved facetted horns.





Have a look on the movement side ....


A pretty sizeable manual movement with diameter at 40.00 mm and height of  6.30mm. 






A filmlet from the caseback side ...



High frequency of 6 Hz or 43,200 VPH. 
The power reserve is 30 hours, and hopefully the production piece may have a power reserve indicator to alert owner.





















Rubber straps with  folding clasp.




Wrist-shots ...













-----------




This message has been edited by Kong on 2010-06-06 11:27:15

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

like the watch but..

 
 By: darma : May 31st, 2010-00:23
i don't like the size. 48mm diameter is huge and if it goes into production it would put me off buying such a piece. It is possible the finished product will have a smaller case at all? thanks darren

Thanks for the inputs ....

 
 By: Kong : June 6th, 2010-11:34
Hi Darren Hopefully it was not my small wrist that blow the watch out of proportion. Must get a more macho wrist next round Likewise I felt it would be nicer if it can be kept at 44mm, however, the movement diameter is already at 40mm. Kong

Great report. Thank you. [nt]

 
 By: VMM : May 31st, 2010-01:36
Would love to see this "thing" working properly, and being reliable soon. Vte This message has been edited by VMM on 2010-05-31 01:38:00

I think ...

 
 By: Kong : June 6th, 2010-11:37
many will have more faith with TAG Heuer after they started delivery of V4 last November, which many doubted would happen. We shall see, what the material scientists/engineers could do in next few years. Kong

Excellent

 
 By: InHavenPro : May 31st, 2010-02:49
report, thank you for such detailed photographs! I like the watch very much but I also think it's too large, it might be a necessity for this movement though.

Same thoughts too...

 
 By: Kong : June 6th, 2010-11:45
Hi Amvox Thanks for viewing. It would be challenging to reduce from current 47mm as the movement itself is at 40mm. Kong

I salute the innovative brand like TAG Heuer

 
 By: ling5hk : May 31st, 2010-04:05
Interestingly, the new concept of pendulum works like tourbilion and more meaningful. I hope TH will manufacture this watch with smaller diameter (not more than 42mm) and longer power reserve (at least 40 hours and above). Any constraint faced by TH? Than... 

The constraint ...

 
 By: Kong : June 6th, 2010-11:50
at the moment, mentioned is the magnets still sensitive to temperature and at the moment may not keep tight rate. Reducing to 42mm, may not be possible as the movement is already at 40mm. Kong

Fascinating technology

 
 By: DSD : May 31st, 2010-06:32
but looks utterly ridiculous at that size. No offense.

So interesting/groundbreaking but

 
 By: Mostel : May 31st, 2010-11:09
The size is crazy and the name 'Graaaaaand' Carrera is a dealkiller. Just my O. I guess a watch brand best known for sport and entry level nice watches should not use a word like Graaaaand, as if an English aristocrat is the target? It always irked me and... 

Have to agree with you ...

 
 By: Kong : June 6th, 2010-11:29
appropriate naming is important! Kong

Beautiful invention...

 
 By: chaser579 : May 31st, 2010-14:51
Reminds me a bit of the inventiveness and imagination behind the Spring Drive from Seiko and, of course, the co-axial technology escapement from Dr. George Daniels. I think Audemars Piguet has a revolutionary movement also, right? The hairspring and escap... 

An interesting alternative ...

 
 By: Kong : June 6th, 2010-11:15
I would say. Yes indeed it reminded about the Spring Drive with the tri-synchro regulator but without the electronics which require battery to power. Most companies can conceptualize, develop and manufacture their movements. However, few can manufacture t... 

what if it was magnetized

 
 By: Ogygia : May 31st, 2010-19:00
If i have to demagnetized it.... will the virtual hair spring lost its magnetism? btw great report! thx

I think the present of ...

 
 By: Kong : June 6th, 2010-10:59
magnet will be detrimental to this alternative regulator. Any upset of balance of the magnetic field in any of the four magnets, doubt the balance wheel will oscillate properly. I like your pictures, they are nice! Kong

Thanks...

 
 By: Ogygia : June 6th, 2010-19:18
I think the situation is same as spring drive as well...and i asked the agent from seiko HK before about the effect on magnetism of spring drive. They gave me an uncertain answer, but i still believe it works unless you bring them into a lab or near some ... 

The electromagnetic field may be disturbed...

 
 By: Kong : June 7th, 2010-02:24
Hi Ogygia Based on my understanding (till someone willing to loan one to test ) , even Spring Drive, it should be affected when near to any strong magnet as the electromagnetic field of the 'braking & release' would be interrupted, affecting the constant ... 

no one willing....

 
 By: Ogygia : June 7th, 2010-03:16
lol....I think no watch owner willing try, but a scientist...as you said... I love the seiko spring drive...especially the smooth motion of the second hand. It really tells the flow of time. I believe I will love this TAG when i meet it...since they are s... 

"Better" is not worded ...

 
 By: Kong : June 7th, 2010-03:38
even in TAG Heuer's press materials. It is an 'alternative' without any electronics (like an integrated circuit, IC) so it is different from Spring Drive. Kong PS : Thanks Elvis for the kind words. Actually each time, I go to a new venue, I hope there is ... 

Thanks Kong..Great report

 
 By: cfdfire : June 1st, 2010-13:23
This is a piece i have been keeping tabs on.Awesome and i have to agree with most here..kinda big.Cheers

Wow! The Size seems to be the major ...

 
 By: Kong : June 6th, 2010-11:53
challenge, as most of us felt the same. Thanks for viewing. Kong

Thanks for the report...

 
 By: aaronm : June 1st, 2010-20:35
What does it sound like? A

Same as the typical ...

 
 By: Kong : June 6th, 2010-10:54
escapement as the escape-wheel and pallets are still being used. The environment was not quiet enough for me to record. Kong

Question about frequency..

 
 By: cbru : June 3rd, 2010-07:01
Very nice project!!! But i realy don't know how they adjust/keep the frequency? Isochronism problems? Some one might explain me?